HOLIDAY PIE MENU

WINONA PIEDER
Brown Sugar Pumpkin Pie
Classic pumpkin pie with brown sugar, ginger, nutmeg, cinnamon, a pinch of clove
and a hint of bourbon baked in an all-butter crust.

Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

PETER PUMPKINHEAD
Praline Pumpkin Pie
Classic pumpkin pie recipe from above with a brown sugar pecan praline topping served in an all-butter crust. If you like both pecan and pumpkin pie it’s like making two great pies into one!
Large $25, Medium $14, Small $7

THE GOBBLEDY GOOKER
Sweet Potato Pie

A southern staple and a similar pie to the classic pumpkin but with sweet potatoes (duh!). Blended with brown sugar, spices and of course, a hint of bourbon (if you haven’t noticed, we like bourbon) baked in an all-butter crust.
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

AGENT COOPER
Tart Cherry Pie,
Classic cherry pie, tart morello cherries tossed in sugar, bourbon and cinnamon

 baked in an all-butter crust
Agent Cooper’s favorite
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

NOTORIOUS P.I.E.
Award-Winning Apple Crumble Pie,
Sweet honeycrisp apples baked to tender perfection in an all-butter crust, topped with a buttery brown sugar and oat crumble
Large $25, Medium $14, Small $7

JON VOIGHT’S CAR
Carmel Apple Pie
Sweet honeycrisp apples baked to tender perfection in an all-butter double or lattice all-butter crust. Apples tossed in Carmel apple sauce and drizzled on top of crust.
Large 25, Medium $14, Small $7

DAMN FINE PIE
Bourbon, Spiced Pecan Pie,
Spiced pecans with a nip of bourbon baked in an all-butter crust
Large $25, Medium $14, Small $7

OH HI, MARK!
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie

Our Damn Fine Pecan Pie w/ a chocolate twist! Baked in an all-butter crust.
Large $25, Medium $14, Small $7

THE LEGEND
Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie Pie,
Katharine Hepburn’s famous simple but delicious brownie recipe with chopped peanut butter cups and creamy peanut butter swirl baked in an all-butter crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

FIB
Fudge Bottom Pie
I recently learned of this pie from UW Madison. It is a famous pie among Badgers and a favorite treat at the student union. Graham cracker crust with a thin chocolate fudge layer covered with a smooth vanilla custard and whipped cream.
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

PIE SEE WHAT YOU DID THERE
Blueberry Lemon Cream Pie,
Lemon cream topped with a blueberry compote
baked in an all-butter or graham cracker crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

PIE KNEW YOU WHEN
Lemon Meringue Pie
Lemon cream topped with a swiss meringue
baked in an all-butter or graham cracker crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

4 small pies for $20 (all pies included)

 MORE PIES….
If they are not listed as out of season, they can also be ordered.

HIGH ON PIE 
Triple Berry Ginger Pie,
Blueberries, blackberries and raspberries tumbled with candied and fresh ginger baked in an all-butter crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

KIND OF BLUE
Blueberry Crumble,
Fresh blueberries tossed in sugar, a hint of cinnamon and lemon juice in an all-butter crust, topped with a buttery brown sugar and oat crumble
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

THE GARRISON KEILLOR (CURRENTLY OUT OF SEASON)
Bebop-A-Reebop Rhubarb Pie,
Straight-up rhubarb, tossed in sugar, a splash of bourbon and a pinch of cinnamon
 baked in an all-butter crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

THIS MUST BE THE PIE (OUT OF SEASON)
Classic Peach Pie,
Fresh and juicy nutmeg-seasoned peaches
baked in an all-butter double crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

A DREAM OF YOU AND PIE
Nutella Brownie Mousse Pie,
Katharine Hepburn’s famous simple but delicious brownie recipe with a Nutella twist, topped with Nutella mousse and hazelnuts
in a homemade graham cracker crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

LIMELIGHT
Key Lime Pie,
Smooth and creamy key lime filling, topped with whipped cream
baked in a homemade graham cracker crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

PIE WANNA BE ADORED
Mississippi Mud Pie,
Katharine Hepburn’s famous simple but delicious brownie layer
topped with chocolate mousse, chocolate wafer crumble and whipped cream

in a homemade chocolate wafer crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

 

We are now taking Holiday Pie orders, please contact me with your order.

For Farmers Markets: I will also make batches of my chocolate chip cookies and molasses sugar cookies.
Cookies
Dozen: $12
Half Dozen: $6

If you have a special message or custom crust request I can accommodate for an additional $5 to $10 per pie.

Advertisements
%d bloggers like this: