Pi Day is on March 14! We’ll be doing some special Pi decor pies. All the pies listed below can be made with a pi design except for rhubarb (if I can find rhubarb that may change). Instead of the Notorious P.I.E. apple crumble we will be substituting with a caramel apple pie with double crust.

If you have a favorite pie that you order from us, we can also accommodate as long as it is in season. Just let me know by March 12 via email htruffer@lakebillypies.com or PM or comment on Facebook.

We make a variety of pies with seasonal flavors from cherry to peach to other specialty pies like our bourbon spiced pecan. If you have a favorite, we probably make it! Once the farmers’ market season starts the menu below will be updated weekly with what will be available at the markets. Various types of pies will be rotated throughout the summer. If you have an absolute favorite and want to preorder a pie for the market or for any special order, reach out to us and we will do our best to accommodate. 

During the holiday season we add pumpkin and other fall and winter flavors. Customers pre-order these pies from a special holiday pie menu.

Please email Heather or find us on Facebook with any catering or special orders. Check out a sample of the pies we offer below.

LAKEBILLY FAVORITES

NOTORIOUS P.I.E.
Award-Winning Apple Crumble Pie
Sweet honey crisp apples baked to tender perfection in an all-butter crust, topped with a buttery brown sugar and oat crumble
Large $25, Medium $14, Small $7

AGENT COOPER
Tart Cherry Pie

Classic cherry pie, tart morello cherries tossed in sugar, bourbon and cinnamon
 baked in an all-butter crust
Agent Cooper’s favorite
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

THIS MUST BE THE PIE 
Classic Peach Pie
Fresh and juicy nutmeg-seasoned peaches
baked in an all-butter double crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

KIND OF BLUE
Blueberry Crumble

Fresh blueberries tossed in sugar, a hint of cinnamon and lemon juice in an all-butter crust, topped with a buttery brown sugar and oat crumble
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

DAMN FINE PIE
Bourbon, Spiced Pecan Pie
Spiced pecans with a nip of bourbon baked in an all-butter crust
Large $25, Medium $14, Small $7

HIGH ON PIE 
Triple Berry Ginger Pie
Blueberries, blackberries and raspberries tumbled with candied and fresh ginger baked in an all-butter crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

THE LEGEND
Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie Pie

Katharine Hepburn’s famous simple but delicious brownie recipe with chopped peanut butter cups and a creamy peanut butter swirl baked in an all-butter crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

JEALOUS GRANDMA
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Fresh strawberries and rhubarb, tossed in sugar, a splash of bourbon and lemon juice and a pinch of cinnamon baked in an all-butter crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

THE GARRISON KEILLOR 
Bebop-A-Reebop Rhubarb Pie
Straight-up rhubarb, tossed in sugar, a splash of bourbon and a pinch of cinnamon
baked in an all-butter crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

FIB
Fudge Bottom Pie

I recently learned of this pie from UW Madison. It is a famous pie among Badgers and a favorite treat at the student union. Graham cracker crust with a thin chocolate fudge layer covered with a smooth vanilla custard and whipped cream.
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

PIE SEE WHAT YOU DID THERE
Blueberry Lemon Cream Pie
Lemon cream topped with a blueberry compote
baked in an all-butter sweet short crust or graham cracker crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

PIE KNEW YOU WHEN
Lemon Meringue Pie

Lemon cream topped with a swiss meringue
baked in an all butter sweet short crust or graham cracker crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

LIMELIGHT
Key Lime Pie
Smooth and creamy key lime filling, topped with whipped cream
baked in a homemade graham cracker crust
Large $20, Medium $12, Small $6

4 small pies for $20 (all pies included)
Large is a 9 inch tin
Medium is a 7 inch tin
Small is a 4 inch tin

Please contact us with any catering or special orders.