We make a variety of pies with seasonal flavors from cherry to peach to other specialty pies like our bourbon spiced pecan. If you have a favorite, we probably make it! Now that the farmers’ market season has arrived, the menu below… Read More

Hi there! My name is Heather, and my husband Tom and I are owners of Lakebilly Pies. I’ve been baking since I was little, and have always found joy in giving loved ones and friends something delicious that I made from scratch…. Read More

Let’s chat about pies! If you want to make a pie order or pick up your pies at the farmers’ market please email Heather with your request, and we will be sure to have them ready to go for you. Contact Heather:… Read More

Where Pie is Passion

Welcome to Lakebilly Pies! I will be selling full- and mini-size pies at farmers markets in Lake County, Ill., this summer. We also take orders and cater!    

Lakebilly Pies
Lakebilly Pies
5.0
powered by Facebook
Marion Hansen Paetznick
Marion Hansen Paetznick
2019-06-02T23:43:04+0000
This pie is SUPERB!! Hands down the best pie I've ever had! The cherry is my favorite. The ultra flakey, buttery crust is what sets them apart. Buy this pie, it doesn't matter what flavor, you will be blown away and so will your guests!read more
Katherine Samantha
Katherine Samantha
2018-09-30T14:10:04+0000
We got an apple and a cherry pie while visiting Fall on the Farm and they were truly amazing. I hate crust, cant stand it, but whatever you guys do to make it so sweet and flaky is true talent. Great job guys.read more
Marisa Rademaker
Marisa Rademaker
2018-09-30T01:23:02+0000
The Legend Pie is truly amazing! Didn’t last long in our house... Thank you! 😍
Jennifer Matoba Waltenburg
Jennifer Matoba Waltenburg
2018-08-15T17:34:51+0000
I wish eating Lakebilly Pies everyday was do-able! Heather's pies are truly delicious!! There is nothing run-of-the-mill about any of them, and I've had my fair share!! Key lime, rhubarb, peach, apple crumble, pecan...... starting to think about what my next pie selection will be......😁read more
Carrie Reffitt
Carrie Reffitt
2018-07-23T17:17:45+0000
My partner and I devoured the cherry pie in 1 day all by ourselves because it was so decadent. Once Heather found a place to purchase black raspberries, she recreated my Grandmother's famous black raspberry pie that transported me back to my Grandmother's kitchen as well as my childhood - that alone meant the world to me! Last week Heather made a lemon meringue pie for my best friend that was so good she instantly ordered up a butterscotch pie for the next delight. You can't go wrong with Lakebilly Pies! Heather is the best!read more
Lori Cepaitis-Lauer
Lori Cepaitis-Lauer
2018-07-11T18:08:20+0000
The key lime pie was the most delicious I’ve had. Looking forward to trying the blueberry- lemon next!
Gloria Edith
Gloria Edith
2018-07-09T03:54:44+0000
Wonderful crust and fresh fillings with harmonizing spices & flavors. I feel the love in these pies! Thanks for all the "home-made-ness"! Yum!!!read more
Alexandra Anne Gustafson
Alexandra Anne Gustafson
2018-06-26T21:32:59+0000
Seriously these pies are amazeballs. So good it's out of this world :)
Jill Fryxell Smith
Jill Fryxell Smith
2018-04-27T21:08:06+0000
Deanna Gilbert
Deanna Gilbert
2018-04-27T03:20:22+0000
Amazing piece of Americana! We ordered two pies for a dinner party with international guests and Heather delivered PLUS! The group was blown away, and it really made the evening special. Can’t wait for the next pie we try!!read more
Damaris Tapia
Damaris Tapia
2018-04-03T20:43:41+0000
Best pie around... and the crust is out of this world!
Carolyn Bonner McCormick
Carolyn Bonner McCormick
2018-02-16T21:14:49+0000
We love Lakebilly Pies! The honey crisp apple is amazing.
Next Reviews